Sister in Islam telah melancarkan "Kempen Jangan Haramkan Buku" setelah Kementerian Dalam Negeri mengharamkan buku terbitan mereka yang bertajuk "Muslim Women and the Challenge of Islamic Extremism".
Pada saya, lebih elok Sister in Islam melancarkan "Kempen Tutup Aurat" dulu sebab amat memalukan bila sebuah persatuan yang menggunakan nama Islam sendiri tidak 'faham' kod etika pakaian Islam.
Saya sendiri tidak berkenan dengan penggunaan perkataan 'sister' kerana seolah-olah seperti meniru nama pendakwah Kristian. Kan lebih elok kalau guna perkataan "muslimah"!
Poskad yang mereka edarkan pun ada lambang Salib yang terbalik. Apa motif mereka? Pihak KDN perlu menyiasat pertubuhan ini secara terperinci, jika persatuan ini mempunyai agenda tertentu yang bertentangan dengan ajaran Islam, lebih baik diharamkan sahaja persatuan ini.
Assalamualaikum,
ReplyDelete1. Telah banyak kali Sisters In Islam (SIS) ni membuat kenyataan/aktiviti yang tidak selari dengan syariat Islam.
2. Tidak mustahil bahawa SIS ini telah "dirasuki" atau berada di bawah pengaruh kuat oleh agen-agen yang ingin memesongkan akidah orang-orang Islam.
3. Seperti komen Nur Aflah, saya juga hairan, bagaimana sebuah organisasi yang kononnya berpaksikan kepada Islam, tidak memenuhi kewajipan menutup aurat.
Assalamualaikum,
ReplyDeleteKomen 'haramkan' sesuatu organisasi yang kita tak suka memaparkan pemikiran sama saja dengan BN.
Jaga, nanti kita sendiri yang diharamkan.
sister in islam.... maksud nya kakak dalam islam. kalau faham mcm tu lah. demokrasi semua orang ada kebebasan. nak di haramkan buat apa. masing masing ada hak. serupa mcm isu forum baru baru ni. nak buat apa, akhir nya nama islam di cemari. dekati mereka dengan ilmu. atau masyarakat islam itu sendiri kena ubah sikap dan pemikiran . tengok lah apa yang berlaku sekarang ini di sebabkan ideology kepartian yang dah tak beradab.. sesama yang tak sister ker atau tak se brother ker pun hina menghina... pakai kopiah ker tak pakai kopiah ker.. bila solat tertib bukan main jaga, tapi lepas solat berkatuk katuk sesama sendiri. nasib baik tak der kapak di tangan . kalau tidak berapa bijik kepala dah jadi kelapa terbelah dua. isu sister sister ni biaq pi lah kat dia orang. aku tak lah setuju... sangat dengan mereka tapi dulu aku pun pernah ikut forum puak puak anti hadis ni... pertengahan 80an tapi kalau hangpa ayat quran pun tak tau makna lupakan, kalau fatihah pun tak tau makna lupakan . jgn nak berdebat dengan mereka. dia nak kempen kita tengok jer. yang penting yang dok berlaku sekarang dlm hal politik yang ni kena betulkan. masing masing dok benci sampai macam nak memusnahkan satu sama lain. lagi ramadhan nak dekat lagi naik hantu semua..tengok saja tulisan tulisan dalam ni cukup lah.. sendiri pun boleh faham.
ReplyDeleteselagi aku larat aku bagi lah pendapat ... the rest i leave it to ALLAH ALMIGHTY.
tapi kalau dah semua masyarakat yang di lahirkan islam ni tak sedar sedar juga ...kita tunggu "CASH" dari ALLAH TAALA. mana kita tau...apa bentuk nya..dulu achech dengan tsunami...maybe kita tanah jerlus ke.. air mata air keluar dari perut bumi ke... kebakaran tak tentu hala ker...serangga pelik pelik keluar ker. atau diri sendiri kot kot semua jadi bodoh tak semena mena. may be boleh berlaku...
bila sebut sister in islam aku tringat lagu "brothers in arm" ... kumpulan dire straits.... best.
shalom
mana boleh biak pi depa...kita wajib perbetul mana yang tak betul. Sisters In Islam wajar ditukarkan nama nya kepada Sisters In Kelambu. Better what...
ReplyDelete'Kempen Tutup Aurat'
ReplyDeleteSaya sokong. Selain tu, 'kempen akhlak mulia' juga perlu ada :)
Jangan lupa sertai forum bersama saya ;)
Layari
http://TeamPemudaUMNO.blogspot.com
• Kesalahan Manusia Yang Berhati Syaitan;- Dari Ibnu Abbas r.a. berkata, bahawa Rasulullah s.a.w. bersabda: “Kelak akan datang di akhir zaman segolongan manusia, di mana wajah-wajah mereka adalah wajah manusia, namun hati mereka adalah hati syaitan; seperti serigala-serigala yang buas, tidak ada sedikit pun di hati mereka belas kasihan. Mereka gemar menumpahkan darah dan tidak pernah berhenti dari melakukan kekejian. Apabila kamu mengikuti mereka, maka mereka akan memperdaya kamu. Akan tetapi apabila kamu menghindar dari mereka, maka mereka akan mencela kamu. Apabila berbicara dengan kamu, maka mereka akan membohongi kamu.Dan apabila kamu memberinya kepercayaan, maka mereka akan mengkhianati kepercayaan yang kamu berikan. Anak kecil mereka bodoh, pemuda mereka licik, sementara yang tua tidak menyuruh berbuat baik dan melarang yang mungkar. Mereka itu sentiasa membanggakan diri dalam kehinaan. Dan meminta apa yang ada pada mereka bererti kesusahan. Orang yang sopan-santun di tengah mereka adalah sesat, dan orang yang menyuruh kepada perbuatan ma’ruf malah menjadi tertuduh, orang beriman di kalangan mereka adalah lemah, sedangkan orang fasik menjadi mulia. Sunnah di tengah mereka menjadi bidaah, sedangkan bidaah itu sendiri adalah sunnah. Maka ketika itulah mereka dikuasai oleh orang-orang paling jahat di antara mereka. Sedangkan orang pilihan apabila ia menyeru, pasti tidak akan dihiraukan.”;- (Riwayat Thabrani).
ReplyDeletemenghina Islam adalah menghina semua umatnya. bukan boleh dibiarkan kerana kalau pun bukan kita yg terkena, tetapi mungkin anak2 atau cucu cicit kita yg akan terkena. kerana mereka mempermainkan Islam sedangkan mereka adalh org2 yg jahil. jgn esok, kita didik anak2 kita dengan Islam, tapi matinya kita nant tiada 1 doa pun kita dapat dari anak2 kita. kerana dakyah2 karut sebegini. tidak menutup rambut@kepala adalah haram, bukan makruh. serupa macam kita pegang babi. haram. tetapi semua org x ambil peduli. sebab ape...sebab dah jadi kebiasaan yg haram itu dihalalkan. FIKIR kalau anda semua org Islam. jika musykil, cari hadis atau kembali kepada al-Quran. bukan guna logik akal yg dangkal tuh.
Salam...
ReplyDeleteYang ni pun saye setuju jgk...
Tapi, nak haramkan terus mungkin agak sukar...
Sye cadangkan supaye digariskan satu peraturan atau tertib untuk mana2 persatuan yang ingin menggunakan perkataan Islam dalam nama persatuan diorang.
Contohnye begini :
mana2 persatuan yang ingin meletakkan Islam sebagai nama persatuan mereka hendaklah menepati syariat agama dengan sempurna dari yang paling basic hingga yang paling rumit... jika tidak, dipersilakan menggunakan name lain...
macam bomoh din cakap, Sister in Kelambu ke, kumbang terbang ke, Persatuan Kakak Kamu ke...
jgn marah haa ;)
Betullah,saya pun dah lama perhatikan Sisters in Islam.Pandai-pandai komen macam-macam pasal Islam tapi semua tak tutup aurat.Memang nak kena siasat.Sokong 100% diharamkan.Kita kena amar maaruf nahi mungkar.
ReplyDeleteOrang mcm ini sudah tidak yakin kepada ALLAH
ReplyDeleteBiarkan.....
Aku dengan agama ku
kau dengan agama kau
Tidak sama dan ianya terpisah.
Sister in islam
ReplyDeleteSister adalah nama timbangan bagi pendakwah kristian.
Sekarang ianya jelas dan nyata -ajarannya sudah menyeludupi ke dalam agama islam. Sister sekarang berada bersama orang islam. Maksud Sister dalam contact ini bukan bermaksud kakak (apa yang difahami oleh kita orang melayu).Makna sister dalam bahasa inggris adalah berbilang maksud.Bila je ada perkataan
islam kita terima sahaja
sebab kita ini berpandangan positif.
akhirnya kita tahu tujuannya.Kita sedar sekarang ..apa lagi kerjakan..dan
haramkan.Besok saya tidak mahu tengok lagi .....ini semua racun dan pengacau jer.++++++++++++++
It seems to me that by not covering up, they are automatically brush aside as the 'non faithful'. Is Islam that superficial? Based on the writings and comments, it does give me the impression that Islam is legalistic and as a result superficial. If you can judge a person faith by just the external (which is easy), then you would also be easily deceived by this simple act of external conformation to the law, don't you think?
ReplyDeleteAs for the the word Sister, surely, you are more widely read and broadminded than this. To connote the word 'Sister' as related to Christianity reveal your narrow mindedness. Sad to say this Nur, but there are no two ways of describing this. We don't call Pendakwah Kristian as Sister, instead, we called them as Missionary.
It's no difference with the typical Malay that will go mad and gungho with the mere mention of Yahudi. Especially when most Muslims that I talk to think that the Jews are the worst people on earth and they are brainwashed by the religious teachers to hate and dislike Jews.
Nur Aflah, could you confirm with me whether Islam teaches one to distance and hate Jews? If no, then i rest my case. If yes, may I know why does a so called good religion like Islam teaches her adherents to hate God's creation?
Nur Aflah, have you read the book? Have you taken a look at the post card? Why are you judging them by your own standard and interpretations of what is right and what is wrong? Have you seen the good that they have done, have you evaluated them thoroughly? Have you ever thought that these are the people that makes non-muslims like me think that Islam is after all a good religion?
Write objectively my dear sister and don't ask people to ban this and that. Islam does not belong to you nor do you have the full knowledge of it.
KaKiaYam
Salam sejahtera Nur,
ReplyDeleteSaya setuju dengan komen kaki ayam. Tak perlulah menghubung kaitkan Agama lain kempen yang dilancarkan oleh SIS. Mereka itu kan Islam, kalau silap betulkan mereka. Jangan sensasikan posting anda dengan memperolok olokkan Agama orang lain.
Dear Chicken Feet aka kakiayam,
ReplyDelete1. Covering up the aurat for Muslim women is mandatory in Islam as stated in the Al-Quran and Sunnah (for Muslim men there are also specific areas of aurat which is mandatory for them to cover). By not following or adhering to such requirements, one is to be considered as opposing or going against Allah S.W.T's commands. This may pose a doubt as to the faith of a Muslim in Islam due to the fact that she does not conform to the requirements in Islam.
2. By now you may ask, what about those who cover up but their other actions reveal that they are "un-Islamic" in other ways ? The answer whether one is Islamic or not is a question which can only be answered in certainty between Allah S.W.T and the particular Muslim in question as this relates to "faith", i.e something which cannot be seen or accounted for by the naked eye. I for one have known Muslims who cover their aurat but their conduct reveals that they have gone against the teachings of Islam in some ways. I have also known Muslims who do not cover their aurat but their conduct showed that they observe other requirements in Islam, such as praying 5 times a day. Be that as it may and notwithstanding what I have mentioned above, covering the aurat is and remains compulsory for all Muslims.
3. What Nur Aflah meant (or at least by what I meant in my earlier posting) is that since the name "Sisters In Islam" in itself potrays the Islamic virtues and since covering the aurat is mandatory in Islam, they must use this organisation to promote the awareness of such mandatory requirement amongst Muslims. I for one, do not and dare not label any Muslims as "un-Islamic" just because they do not cover up their aurat, however the fact remains that by not covering up, they have committed a sin in terms or aurat.
I hope my explanation has addressed your concerns over this issue.
Hi crower,
ReplyDeleteHere are my comments -
1. Yes that is reasonable.
2. "Be that as it may and notwithstanding what I have mentioned above, covering the aurat is and remains compulsory for all Muslims...."
The same goes for all the commandments of God. Tell me which commandments of God that is optional? My point remains, why put such an emphasis on the outer look and why should you deduce a person faith in such a reckless way?
3. It is obvious from the posting that nur aflah is seeking ways to run down SIS. Instead of arguing intellectually, she goes for superficial issues like covering up , having the word Sister which according to her, means Pendakwah Kristian and having an upside down cross in the post card, which actually represents Anti-Christ movement.
I expect more from the writer. If she has a bone to pick with SIS, by all means spell it out clearly. Don't resort to this.
KaKiaYam
And by the way, if you really want to look into questionable NGO, go and take a good look at PPIM.
ReplyDeleteI have observed them for a long time, and while they seems to represent the Muslim, you can see that they make full use of this religious mask to spread hate, fear, doubt and gaining as much influence as they could. They know how to mix righteousness with lies and hidden agenda. These are the real devil in the midst.
The problem is compounded by the fact that Muslims in this country has a terrible herd mentality.
Part of the reason of me getting work up is the fact that thinking writer like Nur Aflah is few and far in between, hence very important to the muslims/malay sections of society. Whatever she wrote will have a significant impact to the readers of this blog.
KaKiaYam
untuk lebih mengetahui agenda SIS, anda semua harus tahu dahulu siapa itu zainah anwar??
ReplyDeletesalamz....
ReplyDeletesaya terharu dengan keprihatinan yg ditunjukkan oleh kakiayam terhadap islam.... akan tetapi dalam setiap pandangan kita, kite perlu memahami agama itu sendiri, jangan kita nilai dari apa yang kite nampak sahaja....
sebagai contoh isu menutup aurat.... saya faham dari segi perspektif kakiayam, setiap tindakan adalah hak individu itu sendiri... kerana kualiti dalaman adalah lebih penting dari luaran... jadi adalah tak adil seseorang itu dikritik hanya dari segi penampilan semata....
tetapi, kakiayam juga perlu faham tentang agama Islam.. kerana penjagaan aurat itu adalah wajib bg setiap muslim, and sebenarnya ia untuk kepentingan individu dan masyarakat... so, bagaimana seseorang itu layak berbicara tentang Islam sedangkan orang itu sendiri tidak percaya pada apa yang dianutinya?
and dalam Islam, ada satu konsep dinamakan amar maakruf nahi mungkar... maksudnya, menerima kebaikan dan menolak kemungkaran... walaupun kemungkaran (tidak menutup aurat) dilakukan oleh individu, tetapi wajib bagi masyarakat utk membetulkannya kerana beban kemungkaran itu akan ditanggung bersama-sama masyarakat yang membenarkannya... so, kalau kakiayam dapat faham konsep tu, sudah tentu kakiayam dapat memahami rasa hati majoriti umat Islam di malaysia ni...
sekian, wassalamz
muhammad wafi -
ReplyDelete"..and dalam Islam, ada satu konsep dinamakan amar maakruf nahi mungkar... ... so, kalau kakiayam dapat faham konsep tu, sudah tentu kakiayam dapat memahami rasa hati majoriti umat Islam di malaysia ni......"
_________________________
sebenarnya konsep ini bukannya asing kepada budaya mereka yang bukan muslim. Kita kan orang timur..., pemikiran kita taklah seperti orang barat yang lebih cenderung kepada sifat individualisma.
Penjelasan yang diberikan oleh saudara wafi diterima dengan hati terbuka.
"...so, bagaimana seseorang itu layak berbicara tentang Islam sedangkan orang itu sendiri tidak percaya pada apa yang dianutinya?..."
layak tak layak, saya rasa bukan kita yang tentukan. Percaya ke tak percaya, itu diantara kita dengan Allah. Bagi saya, tak kisah sangatlah samaada yang bagi nasihat tu orang beriman ke, berpelajaran tinggi ke, ataupun makcik yang jual satay kat tepi jalan. Kalo nasihat tu bernas, terimalah. Tak usah nak pikirkan samada yang beri nasihat tu layak ke tak layak.
Shalom
First word - "ISLAM." We should have been asking all along, "What does the term ISLAM actually mean, anyway?"
ReplyDeleteISLAM comes from the root "slm" or "salama". The word ISLAM in reference to the faith is understood in Arabic as the:
ISLAM means =
1.Surrender
"Give up evil and lusts - give in to the Creator"
2.Submission
"Agree to the terms and conditions of being a servant of Almighty God"
3.Obedience
"Comply with His Commandments to the best of your ability"
4.Sincerity
"Do it all whether or not anyone else notices or cares."
5.Peace
"Accept what Almighty God gives you in this life in serenity."
Now let us consider the next logical question; "What does the term "Muslim" actually mean?"
A "MUSLIM" is one who follows or practices the action of "ISLAM"
In English, when we understand the "ISLAM" is an action, we might say that anyone who "Islams" is an "Islam-ER."
Right? We see in the chart above, in Arabic the "mu" preceding a verb indicates the same thing. Therefore, we would
understand that the one who is actively doing the verb of "Islam" [submission to God] is a "Mu"-Islam or "Muslim."
Now, we should ask, "How does a person become a MUSLIM?"
Only when a person is willing to submit to the Commandments of the Higher Authority from Above, meaning to obey
Allah on His terms does he/she become a " MUSLIM."
maybe its too late to comment on this.nonetheless,to chickenfeet:
ReplyDelete1)"Nur Aflah, could you confirm with me whether Islam teaches one to distance and hate Jews? If no, then i rest my case. If yes, may I know why does a so called good religion like Islam teaches her adherents to hate God's creation?"
Islam does not teach any soul to hate the Jews.It is well stated in the Quraan, Lo! Those who believe (in that which is revealed to you, Muhammad), and those who are Jews and Christians and Sabaeans; whoever believes in Allah and the Last Day and does right, surely their reward is with their Lord, and there will come no fear upon them neither will they grieve] (Al-Baqarah 2:62).
There will be rewards for those who believe in Allah,and as the Jews' Torah is the words from Allah,The God Almighty Himself,they will also gain such reward in afterlife as long as they stick to the Torah's values and do not amend any words in it,that it will dilute the sanctity of the message conveyed by prophet Moses.
The prophet Muhammad also instructed the Muslim to live together with people from other religion such as Jews and Christians in Medina (the first Islamic Constitution) in peace,without hate.
2)Of course to cover oneself is just a small fraction of many practices in Islam.It does not indicate that one is not a good Muslim or a good Muslim by just looking at his or her attire.But having said that,to wear tudung remains compulsory.The actual purpose of the law of Islam to make this compulsory is to prevent "an unethical social state" where adultery happens without marriage.this will prevent more problems such as the sumbang mahram,where one cannot identify his or her own parents or children,and problems like HIV today,which of course predicted by Allah's knowledge.as the Quraan says,
Say to the believing men that they should lower their gaze and guard their modesty: that will make for greater purity for them: And Allah is well acquainted with all that they do.And say to the believing women that they should lower their gaze and guard their modesty; that they should not display their beauty and ornaments except what (must ordinarily) appear thereof; that they should draw their veils over their bosoms and not display their beauty except to their husbands, their fathers, their husband's fathers, their sons, their husbands' sons, their brothers or their brothers' sons, or their sisters' sons, or their women, or the slaves whom their right hands possess, or male servants free of physical needs, or small children who have no sense of the shame of sex; and that they should not strike their feet in order to draw attention to their hidden ornaments. And O ye Believers! turn ye all together towards Allah, that ye may attain Bliss.(AN-Nuur:30-31)
DAh lah x tutup aurat,pandai2 nak buat buku tentang cabaran wanita dalam dunia islam.pelik lah diaorang ni.kesimpulannya dunia nak kiamat
ReplyDeletesalam...
ReplyDeletesaya sgt rasa terhina jika ada org yang cakap bukan2 pasal agama saya mahupun umatnya. pada saya, hanya Mukmin yang layak untuk mengkritik. jika ada bukan kategori Mukmin, selayaknya anda hanya mampu untuk bertanya.
dan untuk perkataan sister itu pula, ianya tiada kene mengene dgn Kristian. Saya merupakan seorg penuntut di universiti islam antarabangsa, dan di sana di antara kaum hawa kami memanggil sister dan kaum adam sebagai brother.
buat kaki ayam pula, there are no such word as hatred in Islam. its common, when there are people who condemn about ur family, ull hate them. dun tell me u dont.coz if yes, thats what we call hypocrite.
ape2 pon, kan xelok mengutuk agama orang lain. bukan aje Islam, sume agama mengajar tu. xslah untuk kite bertanya, tp bukan mengkritik agama org len kerana kite manusia biasa. lemah dlm segalanya.
regards...
Salam,
ReplyDeleteI always had this sort of discussion with my friends when it come to a question of modesty in religion. It may be true Islam is the only religion where most women follow its directives to cover the hair, it's a misconception to say it is the only religion to have such a directive.
For instance have ever any of you wandered why Mary the Mother of Jesus (Peace be upon them) always potrayed wearing veil. Or why christian nun always wear veil. Yes, Christians do direct woman to wear veil (1 Corinthians 11:3-10), yes of course only when she was praying. Albeit that, they are growing numbers of christian opting to wear veil...
http://www.usatoday.com/news/religion/2006-10-04-covering_x.htm
maaf la yer,kpd kakiayam sebenarnye kalu SIS tu btul2 nk juangkan agama islam , kenape diorang terang2 tak mau ikut perintah Allah dalam surah an-Nur ayat 31 yg bermaksud
ReplyDeleteDan katakanlah kepada perempuan-perempuan yang beriman supaya menyekat pandangan mereka (daripada memandang yang haram) dan memelihara kehormatan mereka dan janganlah mereka memperlihatkan perhiasan tubuh mereka kecuali yang zahir daripadanya; dan hendaklah mereka menutup belahan leher bajunya dengan tudung kepala mereka; dan janganlah mereka memperlihatkan perhiasan tubuh mereka melainkan kepada suami mereka atau bapa mereka atau bapa mertua mereka atau anak-anak mereka, atau anak-anak tiri mereka atau saudara-saudara mereka atau anak bagi saudara-saudara mereka yang lelaki atau anak bagi saudara-saudara mereka yang perempuan, atau perempuan-perempuan Islam atau hamba-hamba mereka atau orang gaji dari orang-orang lelaki yang telah tua dan tidak berkeinginan kepada perempuan atau kanak-kanak yang belum mengerti lagi tentang aurat perempuan dan janganlah mereka menghentakkan kaki untuk diketahui orang akan apa yang tersembunyi dari perhiasan mereka dan bertaubatlah kamu sekalian kepada Allah, wahai orang-orang yang beriman, supaya kamu berjaya.
pasai apa diorang tak mau pakai tudung?diorang pikiaq diorang hebat sangat la sampai perintah Allah pun nk lawan..
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDelete